Ryobi ONE+ HP P262 Impact Wrench vs Flex 24V FX1451 Impact Wrench
Quick take: The Flex 24V FX1451 Impact Wrench costs $10 less bare; the Ryobi ONE+ HP P262 Impact Wrench is lighter (3.75 vs 4.2 lbs); they live on different battery platforms (Ryobi ONE+ vs Flex 24V), so the deciding factor is usually which batteries you already own.
| Spec | Ryobi ONE+ HP P262 Impact Wrench | Flex 24V FX1451 Impact Wrench |
|---|---|---|
| Price (bare tool) | $179 | $169 |
| Kit Price | $299 | — |
| Rating | 4.8★ (2,211) | — |
| Category | Impact Wrench | Impact Wrench |
| Battery Platform | Ryobi ONE+ | Flex 24V |
| Voltage | 18V | 24V |
| Motor | Brushless | Brushless |
| Weight | 3.75 lbs (bare) | 4.2 lbs (bare) |
| Released | — | 2022 |
| Fastening Torque | 450 ft-lbs | 600 ft-lbs |
| Nut-Busting Torque | 600 ft-lbs (breakaway) | 750 ft-lbs |
| Anvil | 1/2 in friction ring | 1/2 in friction ring |
| Impacts | 0-3,200 IPM | 0-3,100 IPM |
| Top Speed | 2,800 RPM | 2,700 RPM |
| Modes | 3 speeds + Auto | 3 speeds + Bolt Auto Stop and Bolt Removal |
Pros & cons
Ryobi ONE+ HP P262 Impact Wrench
- ✓In Tool Box Buzz's timed test it pulled eight truck lugs in 22.44 seconds, fastest of every mid-torque tested including Milwaukee and Makita.
- ✓It also won their continuous lag-bolt driving test by a full 25 seconds; the operator called it "an Ox".
- ✓Owners replacing the brushed P261 describe the difference as night and day, and say it takes lug nuts off without drama.
- ✓Auto mode snugs fasteners without over-torquing and spins them out gently in reverse, handy for setting lugs before the torque wrench.
- ✓At $179 bare, or $299 with a 4.0Ah battery and charger, it's the cheapest way into a genuinely useful 1/2-inch mid-torque.
- ✓Grip is sized for larger hands, and the tool is light enough at 3.75 lbs bare to live in a truck for roadside flats.
- ✗Tool Box Buzz's sample repeatedly shut down with all lights flashing after about six seconds of hammering a 1-7/8-inch socket, and the replacement did the same.
- ✗It broke only 510 ft-lbs on their bolt rig, well under the 600 breakaway spec, so heavily seized hardware can outlast it.
- ✗Ryobi recommends a 4.0Ah or larger HP battery, so the small 2Ah packs many ONE+ owners already have aren't the right match.
- ✗It was among the loudest wrenches in that test, a real trade-off for its speed if you work in a closed garage.
- ✗Belt clip isn't included; the tool only accepts Ryobi's optional belt hook.
Flex 24V FX1451 Impact Wrench
- ✓Pro Tool Reviews measured a consistent 414.8 ft-lbs working torque on a 3.5Ah Stacked Lithium pack, at the top of the mid-torque wrenches it had tested.
- ✓600 ft-lbs fastening ties DeWalt's DCF891 for the highest fastening rating here, and its 750 ft-lbs nut-busting trails only the Makita GWT07, DeWalt DCF891 and Metabo HPT WR36DE.
- ✓At 6.3 inches long it's shorter than the Bosch (6.6 in) and Ridgid (6.75 in), which helps behind brake calipers and inside wheel wells.
- ✓The 450 RPM low speed gives real control for starting lug nuts and smaller hardware before stepping up.
- ✓Two automatic modes: one stops at seat to avoid stripping lug studs, the other stops once the nut is loose so it doesn't spin off.
- ✓Street price around $169-$199 bare puts near-flagship torque under most premium-brand mid-torque wrenches.
- ✗4.2 lbs bare (Pro Tool Reviews weighed 4.3) ties the Metabo HPT as the heaviest bare tool here, and it's close to 6 lbs with a Stacked Lithium pack.
- ✗Friction ring only, with no pin-detent version for overhead work where a socket must not drop.
- ✗The Flex 24V lineup is still small and mostly sold at Lowe's, so there are fewer automotive companions like ratchets or die grinders.
- ✗No app connectivity or custom torque presets, only the three fixed speeds and two auto modes.